How you can outsmart the rate headlines (and build optionality)

Most investors run a two step timeline. Wait for the Fed, then lock.

It's intuitive. BUT it's also about three weeks late.

And once you fix the timing, you'll find the 10 year isn't your rate either. Both of those in order.

Fed funds is an administered rate. It changes when a committee votes. The 10 year Treasury is a traded rate. It changes every time the market revises its view of what that committee is going to do, which is continuously, starting weeks before anyone sits down.

Long term mortgage debt prices off the traded one.

What actually moves it?

Three releases do most of the work: CPI, the jobs report, PCE.

Each one forces a repricing of the expected path. By the time the meeting arrives, that expected path is already in the number. What's left to trade on decision day is the surprise, meaning the gap between what the committee does and what was already assumed.

Worth sitting with, because the surprise cuts both ways.

Hawkish tone, bonds sell, your rate ticks up. Dovish dots, bonds rally, your rate improves. Floating into the announcement isn't a strategy. It's a coin flip you elected to take.

You don't have to take it.

Set the number instead

Stop predicting direction. Define your rate.

Run the deal at the rate you need, not the one you want. The rate where the property still cash flows with your assumptions intact and your reserves untouched. That's your strike. It doesn't move when the headlines do.

Concretely: your ceiling payment is net operating income divided by the minimum DSCR your program requires. Solve that payment back to a rate at your loan amount and term, and that's your ceiling. Your strike sits below it by whatever cushion lets you sleep. Worth confirming which DSCR definition you're measured on before you trust it, because programs differ on PITIA versus principal and interest only, and on market rent from the 1007 versus your actual lease. Same property, different ceiling.

Then it's mechanical. Market reaches your number, you lock. It doesn't, you wait or you restructure. No forecast required, which is the entire point, because nobody at any desk has a reliable one either.

Two things before you run this

Your escrow is shorter than the strategy. Thirty days gives you one or two data prints, not six weeks of them. On a short runway the strike matters more, not less, because you get fewer chances and you need to recognize the one you get.

And the benchmark is not your rate.

On DSCR and bank statement paper there's a spread sitting on top of the 10 year, and it moves on securitization demand rather than macro data. Treasuries can rally 20bps and your sheet barely moves. Watch the benchmark for direction, then ask your lender what the spread is doing. Anyone telling you your rate tracks the 10 year one for one is quoting an index, not a price.

The part that decides this

You can't lock a file that isn't submitted.

Every strike strategy dies here. The window opens, and the investor who's been watching bond charts for three weeks still has a credit package in progress and no lender to execute with. The window closes. The investor who was underwritten two weeks earlier locked it.

Being ready is the strategy. Watching is the easy part.

What to do with this

Model the deal and back into your number: Deal Engine

You can send it to me and I'll open a Standing Strike Order. That means we price your file daily against your number and call you the day it prints, so you're not refreshing a chart. Requires a complete file first, which is a good reason to start it before you need it.

PS. The Deal Engine models debt structure, not just payment. Run the same property at three different strike rates and you'll see which one the deal actually survives. Start here

Nothing here is a rate quote, an offer, or a commitment to lend. Rate movement in prior periods does not predict future pricing. Equal Housing Opportunity.More From Me

WORTH RE-READING

Three past issues to revisit before your next move